One of my pet peeves in a story is secrets. Let me elaborate.
In a story, there is always going to be some kind of tension. It has to be there or the plot won’t go. That tension can come from anything: Sauron chasing down the One Ring or Holden trying to keep his life free from phonies, to a guy reluctant to get off the sofa and actually order that pizza. There has to be some sort of tug of war that is what makes the story something people actually want to read. Sometimes that tension is sustained by one character knowing something and another character being kept in the dark.
Now, that’s basically the plot of every murder mystery ever written, and more than half of the thrillers out there. Which makes sense. A murderer who doesn’t want to get caught keeps facts as far away from the detective (or anyone else) as possible. Otherwise, they’re locked up and that more than likely defeats their purpose. However, there are many other thrillers out there— and it feels like about half the romances I’ve come across lately— where a secret is kept ‘for their own good.’
Keeping a safety secret from someone is a great way to get them badly hurt or killed. No, we can’t tell her that the stalker is out of prison! She’d be scared and wouldn’t go to the fundraising gala! And naturally, that’s where she goes, blithely unaware of the stalker waiting to snatch her on the way to the bathroom.
It makes me insane, and honestly, I think it’s incredibly patronizing, not just of the character in question, but of the reader. It assumes that the reader can’t imagine or believe any other way for the hero to be heroic, or for the victim to get into trouble.
So when I write (or look for a good book) I am looking for reasonable excuses for secrets to be kept: people who haven’t spoken recently enough to share information. Actually classified documents. A secret identity! A promise one character made to keep said secret, with a bonus for inner turmoil caused by wanting to reveal the information but also wanting to keep a promise!
I didn’t tell you for your own good, though? Not an excuse. What do you think?